Master vs. Composition: The Two Copyrights in Every Song
By John Cleary and David Slitzky Last updated
The short version
A recorded song is two copyrights. The composition is the song itself: the melody, the harmony and the lyrics, owned by the people who wrote it and their publishers. The master is one particular recording of that song, owned by whoever made or paid for it, usually the artist or a label.
The two have separate owners, separate registrations, separate identifying codes and separate income, and each is divided in its own paperwork. A producer can own a fifth of the song and none of the recording; a label can own the recording and none of the song.
What are the two copyrights in a song?
US copyright law lists musical works, including any accompanying words, and sound recordings as two separate kinds of work. The music business calls the first the composition and the second the master.
- The composition is what stays the same from one performance to the next: the tune, the chords, the words. The Copyright Office says the author of a musical composition is the person who created the music, the lyrics or both. "Publishing" always means the composition.
- The master is one fixed recording: these sounds, captured on this day. The Copyright Office says the author of a sound recording is the featured performer, the producer who captured and edited the sounds, or both.
The law treats a recording as built on top of the song, and is explicit that the two do not merge: a copyright in a sound recording is not the same as, or a substitute for, copyright in the composition it records. Ten recordings of one song are ten masters and one composition.
Who owns the composition, and who owns the master?
Copyright belongs to a work's authors from the moment it is created, and co-authors of a joint work are co-owners. After that, ownership moves only by a signed written transfer, or from the start under a valid work made for hire arrangement, where the employer or commissioning party is the author. Who ends up holding each side depends on what was signed.
| Situation | Composition | Master |
|---|---|---|
| Independent artist who writes, records and releases their own songs | The artist, or the artist and co-writers by their split. | The artist, unless a producer or band agreement says otherwise. |
| Artist signed to a traditional record deal | The writers and their publishers. A record deal is about recordings. | Usually the label. |
| Artist with a publishing deal | Shared with or assigned to the publisher, by the deal's terms. | Unaffected by the publishing deal. |
| Producer who made the beat a song was written over | A writer's share, if they contributed to the writing and the split sheet says so. | Usually none; paid by fee and points under a producer agreement. |
| Session musician paid to play a part someone else wrote | Usually none. | Usually none; the session agreement assigns or licenses their contribution. |
| Featured artist who writes and performs their own verse | A writer's share of the song. | Usually none; paid a fee or royalty under a feature agreement. |
The Copyright Office notes one more route to master ownership: a recording made by an employee in the course of their job is a work made for hire, and the employer is its author. Our work made for hire guide covers when the label works.
How do you tell the two apart on paper?
Each side has its own identifiers and its own registrations.
- The ISRC is a unique and permanent identifier for a specific recording, usually assigned by the label or distributor. A materially different version, such as a remix, gets its own, and an ISRC never identifies the song. See ISRC.
- The ISWC identifies the musical work, whoever records it, and is assigned automatically when the song is registered with a society such as a PRO. See ISWC.
- The IPI identifies a writer or publisher, which is how composition money finds a person. See PROs and registration.
Copyright registration follows the same split. One application can cover a recording and the song it carries only when the same person or entity is the claimant for both; when the song's owners are not the recording's owners, the two must be registered separately. More in copyright basics for musicians.
What does each copyright earn?
The two sides are paid by different organizations, usually for the same use. A single on-demand stream in the US pays the master owner through the label or distributor, and pays the composition's owners twice: a mechanical royalty through The MLC and a performance royalty through their PROs.
The sides are not symmetrical. The owner of a sound recording has a public performance right only for digital audio transmissions, so AM and FM airplay in the US pays the writers and publishers through their PROs and pays the master nothing. Satellite and internet radio do pay the master, through SoundExchange. A sync placement needs a license from each side, each with its own fee.
How music royalties work follows each kind of income from the listener to the owner. This guide's job is the split underneath it.
A worked example: one song, two sets of owners
Maya, an independent artist, writes a song with a co-writer, Leo, over a chord progression and melody that her producer, Dee, built in the session. They agree the composition on a split sheet:
- Maya 50 percent
- Leo 30 percent
- Dee 20 percent
That is the whole song: 50 plus 30 plus 20 is 100.
Maya paid for the recording, and her producer agreement with Dee says she owns the master and pays Dee 20 percent of her net receipts from it, with no costs deducted. Leo sang a harmony and has a session agreement for a flat fee, so he has no share of the master.
In the first year the distributor pays Maya $5,000 for the master. Dee's 20 percent is $1,000, and Maya keeps $4,000. Separately, The MLC pays $800 in mechanical royalties on the composition, to each writer by their registered share (all three self-published): Maya $400, Leo $240, Dee $160, which adds back to $800.
Dee is paid from both sides, under two documents, by two different payers. Leo is paid from one side even though he is on the recording. If anyone treats one number as covering both, someone is overpaid or left out.
Which agreement covers which copyright?
Most music paperwork deals with one side. Knowing which one is the first thing to check in any agreement you are asked to sign.
| Agreement | Composition | Master |
|---|---|---|
| Split sheet | Divides it among the writers. | Not covered. |
| Songwriter agreement | Covers a song a writer writes for an artist, and the writer's credit. | Not covered. |
| Producer agreement | Only if it records a writing share as well. | Fee, points and who owns it. |
| Session musician agreement | Usually not. | The player's fee and the rights in their performance. |
| Featured artist agreement | A written verse is settled on the split sheet. | The feature's fee, royalty and credit. |
| Publishing or admin deal | Who administers or co-owns it. | Not covered. |
| Record deal | Usually not, beyond a controlled composition clause. | Who owns it and what the artist is paid. |
| Sync license | A synchronization license from the publishers. | A separate master use license from the owner. |
| Sample clearance | Permission from the sampled song's owners. | Permission from the sampled recording's owner. |
What happens when someone covers, samples or re-records a song?
A cover is a new master of an existing composition. US law lets anyone record a song that has been released with the owner's authority, under a compulsory mechanical license, without asking the writers, as long as they pay the statutory royalty. The cover's master belongs to whoever made it; the song's writers are paid on it. See cover songs and mechanical licenses.
A sample takes part of an existing recording, so it uses both copyrights: the recording that was copied and the song inside it. Each owner can say no, and there is no compulsory license for either. See sample clearance.
A re-recording is a new master of a song, made without copying the old recording. The owner of a sound recording has no right over an independent fixation of other sounds, even when those sounds imitate the original. That is why an artist who owns their songs but not their old masters can record new versions and own those, subject to any re-recording limits in their old record deal.
Mistakes that blur the two
- Treating producer points as a writing share. Points are a royalty on the master. A producer who also helped write the song needs to be on the split sheet, and one who did not should not be.
- Using a split sheet to divide the recording. A split sheet usually covers the composition only; the master is divided in a producer, band or feature agreement.
- Clearing one side of a sample or a sync. A license from the label alone, or the publisher alone, leaves the other copyright uncleared.
- Assuming a record deal includes publishing, or the reverse. Read which side each deal reaches before you sign it, and look for clauses that reach across, such as a 360 deal or a controlled composition clause.
- Registering the song and forgetting the recording, or the other way round. The PROs and The MLC pay on the composition; SoundExchange and your distributor pay on the master. Each needs its own registration.
Common questions
Is the master the same as the copyright?
No. The master is one of the two copyrights in a recorded song, the one in the sound recording. The other is the copyright in the composition. Someone can own the master outright and own none of the song.
Can you own the composition but not the master?
Yes, and it is common. A songwriter who writes for other artists usually owns a share of the song and none of the recordings. An artist on a traditional record deal often owns their songs, with their publisher, while the label owns the recordings.
Do producers own the master?
Usually not. On a label deal the label normally owns it, and on an independent release the artist usually does, with the producer paid a fee and points. The Copyright Office counts a producer who captured and edited the sounds as a possible author of the recording, so with nothing signed the producer may have a claim to co-own it. A producer agreement settles that.
Does registering a song with a PRO register the master?
No. A PRO registration covers the composition and the writers' shares. The master is identified by its ISRC through your distributor, and its digital performance income is claimed through SoundExchange. Copyright registration with the Copyright Office is a separate step again.
Who owns a master if nothing was signed?
Its authors: the featured performer, the producer who captured and edited the sounds, or both, according to the Copyright Office. Where several people contributed and meant their work to merge, they may co-own it as a joint work. That uncertainty is the reason to sign a producer, session or band agreement before release.
Should I register both copyrights with the Copyright Office?
If you own both, yes, and one application can cover them when you are the only claimant. If someone else owns one side, each owner registers their own. Registration is what lets you sue and claim statutory damages; see copyright basics for musicians.
What is publishing?
Publishing is the business of the composition: registering the song, licensing it and collecting what it earns. A publisher's share of a song is part of the composition, never the master. See publishing and admin deals.
How keysig helps
keysig's agreements are each clear about which copyright they handle. The split sheet divides the composition among the people who wrote it together, with each writer's PRO, IPI and publisher. The songwriter agreement pays a writer a flat fee for a song, which then belongs to the client, with each side's PRO and IPI. The producer, session musician and featured artist agreements deal with the master: who owns it, the fee, the royalty and the credit. The sample clearance agreement asks which side the rights holder controls, master, composition or both, and covers only the rights it lists; any other clearance is the artist's to get. keysig does not register songs or recordings with any organization.
Related guides
- How Music Royalties Actually Work (In Plain English)
- Split Sheets: What They Are and Why Every Song Needs One
- Producer Agreements: Fees, Points, Credit and Who Owns the Master
- Sync License Agreements: Two Permissions, Fees, MFN and Cue Sheets
- Copyright Basics for Musicians: What You Own and How to Protect It
- Releasing a Cover Song: Mechanical Licenses Explained
- Record Deals Explained: Advances, Recoupment, and Who Owns the Masters
- PROs and Registration: How Songwriters Get Paid for Performances
- Music Publishing Explained: Publishing Deals vs. Admin Deals
- Sample Clearance: How to Clear a Sample, What It Costs and What the Law Says
- Signed Agreements, Ownership Records and Exports
About the authors
John Cleary Co-Founder, keysig
A classically trained musician and producer who spent 15 years building A&R, sync, and music strategy for labels and brands like Atlantic Records, Audiomack, and Epidemic Sound.
David Slitzky Co-Founder, keysig
GRAMMY-nominated audio engineer who spent over a decade in the studio with artists like The Roots, Usher, and Travis Scott before spending eight years running music strategy and A&R at Epidemic Sound.
keysig is not a law firm and this is not legal advice. Music rights are nuanced. Consult an entertainment attorney for your specific situation.